Survivor 51, Episode 6 "I Love Crying" Gameplay Breakdown
"Good luck putting clothes on me!"
-Devin Way
This episode wasn't a flashy one, but it was interesting due to the emotional dynamics on Savu. It was fascinating to watch this incredibly unusual scenario play out. It just goes to show; Survivor doesn't always need to be flashy to be engaging television. I will admit that I wanted more fireworks from the Dina tribe after Linnea's elimination. I was hoping for a crazier fallout, but what can you do? Anyway, let's get into who played well and who sucked.
Who Played Well:
I really liked how both Cristian and Lewis handled the game after Linnea's elimination. Cristian had his eyes opened and realized he couldn't just stay Savu strong all the way to the end. He needs more dynamic relationships than that. And Lewis didn't hold a grudge against Cristian, Eric, or Sharonda for voting for him. He got right back to work and was open to working with any of them. I think the strategic conversation Cristian and Lewis had in this episode could greatly benefit both of them.
I don't have anyone from Savu in this section, so we'll move onto Toka, and I only have one person here and that's Kristin. She's really made good inroads with this tribe and even though she has no interest in working with Mike, she had plenty of strategic conversations with him and is keeping the door open. It was great for her to go on the Summit and even better that she volunteered to go to Exile Island. I think having the power to control the limited power of the Tethered Idol is better than the off-chance someone might save you with it. Plus she got more information on the Idol on Exile Island, which puts her in a great spot for the Merge.
Who Sucked:
Back on Dina, I don't think Eric or Kilby handled the aftermath of Linnea's elimination particularly well. Eric was incredibly emotional, which makes him come off as an unreliable alliance partner, but I don't think Kilby did a great job of reassuring him either. I think this relationship could have been repaired quickly if either one of them had handled this just a little bit better.
Sharonda made a mistake in not going to Exile Island. I think it seemed pretty obvious that there would be an additional twist involving the Tethered Idol at Exile Island. It's not a particularly powerful Advantage based on the initial information they were given. I'd want to go to Exile to see if there was more to it. I think taking the food was short-sighted and now that Ori is gone, I wouldn't be surprised to see Sharonda go in the next couple of votes.
Over on Savu, this was the time for both Devin and Jelly to turn on one another. I get that this was a more complicated situation than it is on paper, but putting that aside for a moment and just focusing on what gives them the best shot to win, voting out Ori was the wrong move. They are seen as a tight pair, which will draw attention to both of them after the Merge. I think Ori would have been just as loyal to either one of them. Taking out either Devin or Jelly would give the other two a much smaller target moving forward. I also don't like that Jelly told the others about her Idol. I don't know if Devin will use that against her in the future, but he could.
Back on Toka, this tribe could definitely use a Tribal Council to relieve some tension, so that makes me really happy that they won every Immunity. Brady, Maggie, and Mike are all getting on each others nerves. It makes me wonder who will turn on the others first. All of them need to chill out and go with the flow a little bit more. Brady is over-bearing, Maggie is lacking awareness, and Mike needs to learn how to play the social game. Mike also wanted to go on the Summit, which was actually the right call for him, but he just allowed Thien An to make it a vote to let Kristin go. Mike needed to put his foot down and make it a random draw. It's not like insisting on this would put him in any worse of a position. What's he gonna do? Lose more? This a chance at a home run and he just let the pitch sail by.
I didn't get enough from Carter or Thien An for me to say either way.
As for Ori, he had a tough draw. I think he made the right moves in taking out Jenna and Alexis and then he made good arguments to try and get Devin or Jelly to flip. I just don't think it was ever going to happen. Maybe if he had gone to Exile Island and gotten the Tethered Idol instead of taking the food, he could have possibly bluffed his way through this tough situation, but even that is a stretch. Sometimes, you can do everything right and still lose. That isn't failure, that's life. And while Ori didn't do everything right, I don't think he had a chance of making it through apart from the Shot in the Dark going his way or winning Immunity.
Verdict:
Best Player of the Episode goes to Kristin Flickinger for having strategy talks with Mike, going on the Summit, and getting the Tethered Idol by going to Exile Island.
Worst Player of the Episode goes to Mike Pinsky for his terrible social game and missing the opportunity to go to the Summit.
Merge time! I have no idea how this is going to shake out. We have so many splits and factions that it could go any which-way. I think this season has just solidified the two tribe to three tribe to merge format as being my favorite.
I'm excited to see what happens next! If you liked this breakdown, check out my other write-ups at www.stacysbloggoingon.blogspot.com/.